Text messages from Koppenhaver's phone would call into question the validity of Mackinday's statements about the attack, Sua said.
Prosecutors said they didn't know Koppenhaver had kept the phone. The ex-Bellator MMA and Ultimate Fighting Championship fighter was arrested in California a week after the Aug. 8, 2014, assault and has been in custody since.
The judge ordered Sua to turn that phone over to prosecutors by next week.
The defense attorney said text messages from the night of the alleged attack showed "ample evidence of (Mackinday) enticing Mr. Koppenhaver to come over that evening, ample evidence of her consenting to him being there."
Bluth said she needed to review the entirety of the messages.
Dun dun dunnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn